Cardinal Burke voices concerns over consistory format and upcoming SSPX consecrations
The American cardinal offered measured criticism of the synodal approach used at the recent gathering of cardinals and expressed worry about the Society of Saint Pius X's planned episcopal ordinations.
Cardinal Raymond Burke has shared his assessment of the recent Extraordinary Consistory in Rome, offering qualified praise for the restoration of regular consistories while raising questions about the synodal format used for discussion. He also expressed strong concern about the Society of Saint Pius X's upcoming episcopal consecrations scheduled for July 1.
Speaking after the gathering, which brought nearly 180 cardinals to the Vatican for the second such meeting under Pope Leo XIV, Cardinal Burke said he welcomed the return of consistories as a regular feature of Church life. He noted that these meetings allow cardinals to become better acquainted and to discuss important matters facing the Church.
However, the cardinal voiced reservations about the small-table "synodal" group method that has replaced the traditional open debate format. He said the concept of synodality itself "remains unresolved" and requires a critical examination to determine whether it is an appropriate way to conduct consultation in the Church. The agenda, he observed, focused heavily on broad global concerns rather than specific crises facing the Church.
Faithful news, every morning.
Biblical truth. Timely stories. Encouragement for your day.
Free, in your inbox. No spam, ever.
Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.
Psalm 119:105
On the subject of the SSPX, Cardinal Burke downplayed the Society's argument that a state of emergency justifies proceeding with episcopal consecrations without papal mandate. He said the present situation does not constitute a true emergency, because the faithful in the SSPX can still live their Catholic faith within the Church. He emphasized that no situation justifies an intrinsically evil act.
The cardinal expressed hope that the Holy See would appoint one or more cardinals to meet with SSPX representatives, potentially leading to more productive dialogue than recent negotiations. He dismissed rumors that all SSPX members might be declared excommunicated, noting that many faithful attached to the Society, including priests, do not possess a schismatic spirit but simply love the traditional form of the Roman Missal.
This article was independently written by Christian Newsline based on the linked reporting.
