Cardinal Müller compares SSPX to ancient schismatics, warns against upcoming episcopal consecrations
The former Vatican doctrine chief says the Society of St. Pius X’s planned July 1 ordinations of four bishops without papal approval are objectively schismatic, while affirming the legitimacy of the Traditional Latin Mass.
Cardinal Gerhard Müller has sharply criticized the Society of St. Pius X’s decision to proceed with the consecration of four bishops without a papal mandate, calling the act schismatic and comparing the traditionalist group to the Donatist heretics of the early Church. In an interview with EWTN News In Depth, the former prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith stressed that the issue is one of authority, not of liturgical preference.
The German cardinal stated that episcopal ordinations performed “without the pope are absolutely impossible, against the will of God,” and declared that those who carry them out place themselves outside the Catholic Church. He emphasized that this judgment is based on “objective criteria” rather than personal opinion. Without a papal mandate, the consecrations would be valid but illicit, triggering an automatic excommunication under Church law.
The SSPX plans to ordain four priests as bishops on July 1 at its seminary in Écône, Switzerland, including American Father Michael Goldade. The ceremony echoes the 1988 consecrations performed by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, which led to a formal break with the Vatican. The society’s superior general, Father Davide Pagliarani, has cited a “state of necessity,” noting that only two aging SSPX bishops remain to ordain new priests for the group.
Faithful news, every morning.
Biblical truth. Timely stories. Encouragement for your day.
Free, in your inbox. No spam, ever.
Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.
Psalm 119:105
Cardinal Müller drew a direct parallel between the SSPX and the Donatists, a schismatic movement in North Africa opposed by St. Augustine. He warned that the society’s patron, St. Pius X, “will pray against these people who abuse his name.” The cardinal also noted that Pope Leo XIV, who took office in March, is himself an Augustinian, suggesting a particular sensitivity to the issue of schism.
The cardinal made a clear distinction between devotion to the Traditional Latin Mass and rejection of papal authority, calling them “two absolutely different questions.” He faulted bishops who forbid the traditional liturgy as “authoritarian,” while insisting that the SSPX’s defiance of the pope remains unacceptable. Asked what faithful who attend SSPX Masses should do if a schism occurs, Müller said they “shouldn’t go, and cannot participate in the Masses of schismatic priests and bishops.”
The Vatican’s current doctrine chief, Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, warned on May 13 that the planned consecrations would constitute “a schismatic act.” The SSPX rejects this charge, maintaining that such consecrations do not by themselves break communion. On June 24, the society sent Pope Leo and the College of Cardinals a “Declaration of Catholic Faith” defending its position. Cardinal Müller also commented on the June 26–27 consistory, which he said would likely address atheism and artificial intelligence, and renewed his criticism of the synodal process, which he said had been “abused” to advance ideas contrary to Church teaching on the priesthood and marriage.
This article was independently written by Christian Newsline based on the linked reporting.
