National African American Fellowship calls for more discussion on Southern Baptist constitutional amendment regarding women pastors
The nearly 4,000-church network says the proposed Truth and Unity amendment represents a shift from the convention’s traditional bottom-up structure and urges broader conversation before a final vote in 2027.
The National African American Fellowship, a network of nearly 4,000 Southern Baptist churches and missions, is urging extended dialogue among convention members over the proposed Truth and Unity constitutional amendment. The amendment, which would bar churches from affirming or appointing women to the role of pastor or allowing them to preach to the assembled congregation, was approved by 74.66 percent of messengers at the 2026 SBC annual meeting. NAAF noted that the 25.09 percent who voted against the change represents a significant minority that warrants further discussion.
Jerome Coleman, the newly elected president of NAAF and senior pastor of Crestmont First Baptist Church in Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, said the amendment introduces a top-down mandate that alters the Southern Baptist Convention’s cooperative identity. He emphasized that the convention has historically operated as a voluntary fellowship of autonomous local churches, not a hierarchical denomination. Coleman argued that turning a confession of faith into a constitutional enforcement mechanism infringes on the right of local congregations to discern their own pastoral leadership.
NAAF raised concerns about the amendment’s ambiguous language, particularly the phrase “assembled congregation.” The group questioned whether this would apply to a female youth minister teaching teenagers and male chaperones at camp, a woman leading a coed Bible study, or a female missionary teaching doctrine on the mission field. The network warned that such vague wording could lead to selective enforcement and create chaos in daily church life, potentially policing the very teaching and shepherding roles that women already fill in many congregations.
Faithful news, every morning.
Biblical truth. Timely stories. Encouragement for your day.
Free, in your inbox. No spam, ever.
Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.
Psalm 119:105
Albert Mohler, president of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and the amendment’s author, addressed some of these questions in a press conference following the vote. He stated that the amendment applies only to the setting of the church and specifies the function of preaching to the gathered assembly, not to Sunday School classes or missionary services. He also said he does not believe the convention has the will to interfere in the internal life of individual churches. However, NAAF noted that Mohler’s verbal clarifications are not part of the amendment’s official text, leaving room for interpretation.
Coleman said he plans to encourage dialogue by first meeting with NAAF’s board to discuss church autonomy and perceptions of the amendment. He also intends to reach out to the Black Collective of fellowships representing the African diaspora. The board will develop an action plan that may include recorded panel discussions for the broader SBC family, with opportunities for continued conversation. Coleman expressed hope that those who support the amendment would agree to a recorded discussion, allowing others to see that churches with women on staff in pastoral roles are not embracing liberalism but are acting on biblical convictions.
Coleman also warned that the amendment could set a precedent for further constitutional mandates, such as requiring pastors to keep their children under control with all dignity. He noted that faithful, Bible-believing Christians can arrive at different conclusions about the application of pastoral texts without discarding biblical authority. NAAF called for a return to open dialogue, recognizing that unity in the convention has historically been maintained by a shared commitment to Christ and the Great Commission, not by edict or enforcement.
(Picture courtesy of the Baptist Press)
This article was independently written by Christian Newsline based on the linked reporting.
